Featured 1
Photo: Courtesy
The meeting between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen may well enter the history books as an unprecedented diplomatic encounter. Never before have the leaders of these three major powers sat together in a trilateral meeting of this nature. Yet, the temptation to compare their gathering with the historic Yalta Conference of February 1945 is misplaced. For all its symbolism, Shenzhen bears little resemblance to the conference that helped shape the post-Second World War international order.
The comparison is understandable. Both meetings brought together leaders representing three formidable powers at a moment of considerable international uncertainty. Both raised questions about the future distribution of global influence and the possibility that major powers might determine the fate of smaller countries. And both have implications for the international balance of power. But the similarities largely end there.
At Yalta, US President Franklin D Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin were not simply three powerful men seeking diplomatic accommodation. They were wartime allies, united by the overriding objective of defeating the Axis Powers. Their armies had fundamentally altered the military and political landscape of Europe, and the conference was convened to negotiate the arrangements that would follow the inevitable German surrender. The decisions taken there concerning Germany, Poland, Eastern Europe and the establishment of the United Nations, replacing the League of Nations, helped lay the foundations of the post-war international system.
Nothing remotely comparable has emerged from Shenzhen.
For starters, the three leaders assembled in China are not wartime allies. They are strategic competitors with sharply divergent interests, even when they occasionally find common ground in challenging aspects of the existing international order. Washington regards Beijing as its principal long-term strategic competitor, while Moscow remains deeply antagonistic towards the Western security architecture.
China, meanwhile, has its own ambitions and is unlikely to subordinate them to either American or Russian calculations. Having emerged as an economic and technological powerhouse, increasingly capable of challenging American primacy, Xi Jinping's greatest diplomatic achievement in Shenzhen may have been the opportunity to project China as an indispensable convening power, capable of bringing Washington and Moscow to the same table without making substantial concessions of its own.
The actual outcome of the meeting reinforces the distinction. The three leaders issued a declaration calling for United Nations reform, greater nuclear restraint and increased supplies of refined petroleum products. Yet the declaration conspicuously avoided the two major conflicts dominating international affairs: the war in Ukraine and the US-led war in Iran. Nor did the meeting produce any discernible breakthrough on nuclear disarmament.
This does not diminish the importance of the Shenzhen meeting. Direct engagement among the leaders of the world's three most consequential powers is valuable, particularly at a time when nuclear risks, armed conflicts and economic fragmentation threaten international stability. But symbolism must not be confused with substance. Yalta was a conference that helped determine the architecture of a new international order. Shenzhen, at least for now, is an encounter between three leaders seeking to advance their respective national interests without necessarily sharing a common vision of the world.

















Leave a Comment
Recent Posts
Shenzhen was no Yalta: The Lim ...
The meeting between US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladi ...
For the first time, UN’s highe ...
In a landmark judgment, the United Nations’ top court ruled Thur ...
DFC engagement to mobilise private investment, advan ..
France to celebrate French Week in Dhaka; André Malr ..
The Roots of Macron’s Failure
The Silver Lining of a Data-Center Slowdown